Seasonal Menu

Here at Lucy’s, we like to keep things fresh. The same goes for our menu! Each season, we feature new culinary creations prepared with the highest quality ingredients. We also offer box lunches, deli platters, and catering for special occasions!


Our Famous Deli Sandwiches

                             All of our sandwiches are served with a kosher pickle & choice of a side: Potato Salad, Cranberry Wheat Berry Salad, Carrot & Celery Mix with Dip or Chips.
Or add a cup of soup for $1.75 – Extra Side $1.60

Lucy’s New York Style Deli Sandwich $8.25
Served with mayo, deli mustard, lettuce, tomato, shredded carrots & your choice of bread, one meat & one cheese – served hot or cold.

Bread: Multi-grain, Sourdough, Rye, Garlic Herb Wrap, Kaiser Roll or Panini Bread
Meats: Boar’s Head Pastrami, Chicken, Smoked Ham, Roasted Turkey Breast, Albacore Tuna Salad or Salami
Cheeses: Pepper Jack, Swiss, Cheddar or Provolone

Fall Menu Sandwiches

* Fall Turkey Melt – $8.25

Oven roasted turkey, gouda cheese,

cranberry chutney, honey sage aioli and

mixed greens grilled on multi-grain.


 * Apple, Ham & Cheddar – $8.25

Tavern ham, cheddar cheese, sliced apple

and dijionaise grilled on sourdough.


* Three Cheese Pear Melt – $8.25

Cheddar, gouda and havarti with sliced pear, sunflower seeds and honey sage aioli grilled on multi-grain.



* Southwestern Wrap – $8.25

Salsalito Turkey, pepper jack cheese, black bean salsa, lettuce and tomato with chipotle lime aioli in a garlic herb wrap served hot or cold.


 * Sara Sue – $8.25

Ham, Cheddar Cheese and Caramelized Onion with Dijonaise grilled on Sourdough.

 * Becky’s Sassy Turkey – $8.25

Boar’s Head Salsalito Turkey & Bacon, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Chipotle Lime Aioli grilled on Multi-grain.

* Lucy’s Famous Reuben or Rachel – $8.25

Reuben has sliced Boar’s Head Pastrami, Kraut, Caramelized Onion, & Swiss Cheese with Louis Dressing grilled on Rye Bread. Rachel is a Reuben made with Turkey!

* Chippewa Hot Beef  – $8.25

A generous portion of Lucy’s House Roasted Beef, Provolone Cheese, a thick slice of Raw Onion, and our special Horseradish Sauce on a Fresh Baked Kaiser Roll.

Lucy’s Famous Pizza – $7.75

Canadian bacon, pineapple with red sauce, oregano, garlic and mozzarella, romano and provolone cheeses.

Italian sausage, peppers, and mushrooms with red sauce, mozzarella, romano and provolone cheeses.

Very Veggie:
Artichokes, sun dried tomatoes, mushrooms, and peppers with red sauce, mozzarella, romano and provolone cheeses.

Spicy Pepperoni:
Spicy pepperoni with red sauce, mozzarella, romano and provolone cheeses.

Feta, mozzarella, rosemary, red onion, kalamata olives and tomato with romano and provolone cheeses.



Lucy’s daily homemade soups (changes daily)
All soups come with Lucy’s house bread

Cup – $2.59
Bowl – $4.59
Take Home Soup – 1 Quart – $9.99

Lucy’s Salads

All salads come with Lucy’s house bread

Dressings: Balsamic vinaigrette, Greek vinaigrette, Creamy Blue Cheese, Cilantro-Buttermilk Ranch, Caesar, French & Ranch Lo-Calorie

Garden Salad – $7.30 1/2 Salad $5.25
Tossed romaine, shredded carrots, cucumbers, red onion, tomatoes, peppers, homemade croutons topped with blue cheese and your choice of dressing.
With Grilled Chicken Breast – add $2.25

Greek Feta Salad – $7.30 1/2 Salad – $5.25
Tossed romaine, kalamata olives, cucumbers, red onion, pepperoncini and tomatoes topped with feta cheese and Greek vinaigrette dressing.
With Grilled Chicken Breast – add $2.25

Caesar Salad – $7.30 1/2 Salad – $5.25
Tossed romaine, tomatoes, red onion, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing.
With grilled Chicken Breast – add $2.25


$4.25 Kids Menu

Turkey or Ham & Cheese on a Kaiser w/Chips
Grilled Cheese with Chips
PB & J with Chips
Mac & Cheese


Lucy’s Gooey Rolls – $2.50
Scones – $2.00
Muffins – $1.75
Brownies & Bars– $2.50
Cookies – $.95

Breakfast – Served to 11:00 am

Quiche – $4.25
Quiche w/ Muffin – $5.75
Veggie & Cheese Omelet w/Toast – $6.00 (with Ham, Bacon or Sausage – add $1.50)
Bagel w/Cream Cheese or Peanut Butter – $2.00
Bagel Egg & Cheese Sandwich – $4.00
Bagel, Egg, Cheese & Meat – $5.50
Bagel only – $1.25
Yogurt Fruit Parfait – $3.65                                                                                                                                                            NEW Breakfast Pizza – (3 choices) – $7.75


Espresso Drinks & Specialty Coffees

Lucy’s Fresh Brewed Coffee (reg and decaf) -$1.75
Hot or Ice Tea – $1.69
Lemonade – $1.69
Milk (Regular or Chocolate) – $1.30
12 oz. Hot Chocolate – $1.80
Canned Soda – $1.50
Izze’s Juices – $2.00
Juice – $1.50
Bottled Water – $1.50
Bottled Soda – $1.75
Leinie’s Beer – $2.75
Micro Brew Beers – $2.75
Wines By The Glass – $4.50
Fruit Smoothies 16oz. – $3.95
Mango ~ Strawberry ~ Wildberry ~ Raspberry ~ Banana


Download Lucy’s Seasonal Menu

Lucy’s Menu Fall 2017